Space Monkey

I know nu metal gets hammer, and IMO nothing Soulfly does can compare to Sepultura's material pre-Max Cavalera's departure, but since he split Sep have been pretty average and I think Soulfly kick ass.

hodor

Soulfly I like, however, I like Sepultura much better. Also, if you have heard the two in concert, you would be a fool to say Soulfly is better in concert.

Space Monkey

I disagree heartily; I've seen the two live, (Sep more than once) and stand by my original statement. Nothing can touch old Sep, especially up to Arise. But alas, without him, they fell and Soulfly rose from their ashes.
Its a close race so far!!!!!!

Circus Cranium

I've only seen Soulfly in concert, not Sepultura. But as far as music, I like Sepultura's better, judging merely by the one CD I have. Either way, we like Max, Max is cool, yay Max.

hodor

Rose from their ashes as if they were the best. I think not my friend. I would put Slayer above the old Sep and the new and Soulfly, I would also put MachineHead above them both. Not to forget to mention Pantera who is not better than Slayer but coming right up there.

Space Monkey

Oh my goodness I'm all a tremble with the heresy I'm hearing.
Except for the Slayer comment, I'm with you there - but Machine Head and Pantera?????

I've seen all these bands live, I even saw Machine Head support Slayer, and in the gig stakes this is the list in order of talent, tightness, power and technical aptitude:

Slayer
Old Sep
Soulfly
Pantera
Machine Head

Did you know that Logan Mader actually left Machine Head to join Soulfly when they first formed? Because the man knew a good thing when he saw it

hodor

heresy is a religious word. Are you a religious man?

So long as you admit Slayer is the greatest metal band ever I don't care where you put machinehead or pantera.

SLAYER!

knivesout

Hah! What about Exodus, Testament, Obituary, Celtic Frost...

I voted for Sep. 'The past reborns the storms' hell yearghhhhh \m/

__________________
INCISION : Webcomic. Words: Me. Art: George. Updates every 3 days or so.

cornelius

Sep allright! though "prophecy" has somethin good going on

ChasenFate

I saw Sepultra on their Chaso AD tour and they were bad ass. I got Igor's (The drummer) autograph...Is he still with them? I lost interest in them when they put out Roots. I do not know much on Soul Fly. I think I have heard a song or two, I can't recall off the top of my head.

Asariel

I must say, I've only heard two or so songs of sepultra, but Soulfly are real good. When Im in the mood of listening to this sort of music I listen to KoRn too. Anyone enjoy listening to KoRn?

cornelius

I do very very much! I was longing for a KoRn fan so hard, and now I found you! I'll instantly add you to my buddy list!

ChasenFate

KoRn are very good. I saw them whe they were touring on their Life is Peachy album.

cornelius

I haven't seen them yet, I was Ill when they came to Belgium ( two years in a row... Is this coincidence... I think NOT!)

I like loads of their songs. Could start a thread over it, this one is about sep...

Asariel

Hahaha, how nice of you. But dont expect me to know birthdates of the artists and stuff like that... I enjoy their music, but Im no hardcore fan of them that knows everything...

I suppose starting a new thread would be a good idea